Tribi Reiki

How to spot fake or dyed crystals

By Hannah Whitlock · 5 min read

Not every stone sold as a crystal is what the label says. Many are real minerals that have been dyed, heated or coated, and some are manufactured glass. None of this is illegal if it is disclosed, so the key is to ask.

Common substitutions

  • Dyed agate: very bright blue, pink or green slices are almost always dyed.
  • Goldstone: a sparkly stone sold as a crystal that is actually man-made glass with copper particles.
  • “Apache tears” and some obsidian: natural obsidian is volcanic glass, but some black pieces are simply manufactured glass.
  • Heated amethyst sold as citrine: a lot of deep orange citrine is heat-treated amethyst.
  • Coated quartz: rainbow “aura” stones have a metallic coating added in a lab.
  • Dyed howlite sold as turquoise: a cheap stone coloured to look like a more expensive one.

Simple checks

  1. Look for colour pooling in cracks and edges, a sign of dye.
  2. Look for tiny round bubbles inside the stone, which point to glass.
  3. Feel the temperature. Natural stone feels cold for longer than glass or plastic.
  4. Compare the price. A large perfect specimen at a very low price is rarely what it claims to be.

Ask the seller

Ask three questions: what is the stone, where is it from, and has it been dyed, heated or coated? A good seller answers easily. Treated stones are not worthless, but you should know what you are paying for.

Enjoy it anyway

A dyed or coated stone can still be beautiful. What matters is that it is described honestly, and that you handle it with the right care. See also how to choose your first crystal.